VintageRoam
ThriftBuysConsigns

Buffalo Exchange

Resale chain in Portland Downtown · One of two Buffalo Exchange stores in Portland

Closed · opens tomorrow 11 am1036 W Burnside St · map ↓

Buffalo Exchange reviews

3.7 ★★★★☆ 495 reviews

Cramped racks of used clothing and shoes fill this small downtown shop, with some vintage and unusual pieces. People who bring items to sell describe low offers and, some of them, rude staff.

Written with AI from its 335 written reviews and the facts below, checked against them and approved by a separate AI model, Oct 2026. How we write these

335 written reviews · 36% five-star · 27% one or two stars · 37 in the past year · reviewed since 2010

Its 335 star ratings: 121 five-star, 71 four-star, 53 three-star, 36 two-star and 54 one-star, the first in November 2010 and the latest in September 2026.

What its 335 written reviews keep saying
  • 42Friendly staffStaff described as kind, helpful and attentive, including to people selling items
  • 25Wide varietyGood range of clothes and shoes, even for a small store
  • 7Well-chosen stockStock is hand-selected by buyers, and recent shoppers find prices above typical thrift
  • 23Prices seen as highMany call it overpriced for used, stained or lower-quality clothing
All 17 themes ↓
Buffalo Exchange, 1036 W Burnside St
Buffalo Exchange, 1036 W Burnside St, inside
Buffalo Exchange, 1036 W Burnside St · photos from its business listing

It buys from the public and takes consignments

Sell your things Yes, it buys from the public. Buys clothing every day, no appointment: 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit, paid the day you sell. From buffaloexchange.com ↗
Consign Yes, it sells things for you on consignment. Case by case, for higher-end items; 50% in cash once the item sells. From buffaloexchange.com ↗

Not stated on its website or listing: donations. Close by, Goodwill Industries of the Columbia Willamette takes donations (0.2 mi).

Call (503) 222-3418

All 17 themes in its reviews

What they like

  • Friendly staff42 reviewsStaff described as kind, helpful and attentive, including to people selling items
  • Wide variety25 reviewsGood range of clothes and shoes, even for a small store
  • Well-chosen stock7 reviewsStock is hand-selected by buyers, and recent shoppers find prices above typical thrift
  • One-of-a-kind finds4 reviewsRecent shoppers say you never know what you will find, and one usually leaves with a new outfit
  • Fun to browse4 reviewsShoppers say a little digging always turns up something they like
  • Good atmosphere2 reviewsMusic playing makes for a pleasant shopping environment

Prices & deals

  • Good clothing prices14 reviewsSome shoppers find clothing affordable or fairly priced; others see poor value
  • Fair prices6 reviewsOthers find prices reasonable and affordable, especially for consignment-style clothing
  • Cheap name brands2 reviews

Shopping there

  • Small store9 reviewsA little shop with a small space that can feel overcrowded
  • Wide size range2 reviews

Who comes here

  • Worth a trip4 reviews
  • Regular stop2 reviewsRegulars drop in when in the area to look for deals

Common gripes

  • Prices seen as high23 reviewsMany call it overpriced for used, stained or lower-quality clothing
  • Cluttered aisles9 reviewsSmall, packed racks make the store feel crowded to some shoppers
  • Rude staff4 reviewsSome sellers report rude, stuck-up or disrespectful employees
  • High for secondhand3 reviewsSeen as pricey for a thrift or secondhand shop

Known for

  • Edited, stylish secondhand clothing 3 shoppers
  • Buying clothes for cash or store credit 3 shoppers
  • Friendly, helpful staff 3 shoppers

A good fit for

Stylish secondhand shoppersSellers wanting store credit

17 themes from its 335 written reviews, written between November 2010 and September 2026, each checked against the reviews before it appears here. Notes under the themes, “Known for”, “A good fit for”, tips and the price note are written with AI from these reviews, checked against them and approved by a separate AI model.

Selling & consigning

Holds
Up to 5 non-sale items for 24 hours
Payment
Trade cards never expire; take cash, trade or a mix when selling
Consignment split
Consignment for higher-end items, offered case by case; 50% in cash once the item sells
Pays
On the day you sell: 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit; no wait for items to sell
Selling
Buys every day from open to close, no appointment; bring a government ID
From buffaloexchange.com ↗
Before you bring anything, ask
  1. Do you pay cash or store credit, and how much of the resale price?
  2. What don’t you buy right now?
  3. Do I need an appointment, or can I walk in?
  4. What is the split, and when and how do I get paid?
  5. How long do items stay out, and what happens if they don’t sell?

When shoppers are unhappy

32 one- and two-star written reviews since Oct 2023, each read in full; lowballed or turned away when selling comes up most (14).

  • Lowballed or turned away when selling8 in the last 12 months14
  • Prices too high6 in the last 12 months13
  • Rude or unhelpful staff7 in the last 12 months10
  • Item broken, dirty or not as described1 in the last 12 months5
  • Unclear or unfair store policies (bags, fees, minimums)2 in the last 12 months4
  • Dirty, smelly or cluttered store3 in the last 12 months4
One- and two-star reviews by quarter Oct 2023Oct 2026 19 in the last 12 months.

From its own website

What buffaloexchange.com says, read September 2026. Each item links to the page it came from.

Resale store where you sell clothes for cash or trade and shop secondhand fashion, including clothing, accessories and jewelry.

Summed up with AI from its website and approved by a separate AI model.

Hold
Hold up to 5 non-sale items for 24 hours source ↗

How it compares in Portland

Big dot: Buffalo Exchange; small dots: 127 other Portland stores.

One- and two-star reviews27% 0100 A bigger share than 110 of 127 Portland stores.
Reviews the owner answers3% 0100 Answers fewer than 91 of 127 Portland stores.
Say it’s too expensive69 per 1,000 0188 More price grumbles than 111 of 127 Portland stores.
4–5 star reviews, past 12 months35% Before60%Past year35% 35% of the past year’s 37 written reviews give 4–5 stars, against 60% before.

Sells clothing and vintage clothing

  • ClothingShoppers mention it · Listed as a used clothing store
  • Vintage clothingShoppers mention it

Seen as high. 23 reviews say prices are too high; 6 call them fair. Complaints cite a $24 pit-stained Zara shirt and a $25 used scarf; others call prices affordable, fair or reasonable.

Hours and getting to 1036 W Burnside St

Monday11 am–8 pm
Tuesday11 am–8 pm
Wednesday11 am–8 pm
Thursday11 am–8 pm
Friday11 am–8 pm
Saturday11 am–8 pm
Sunday11 am–7 pm

1036 W Burnside St, Portland, OR 97209

Directions to 1036 W Burnside St ↗
Payment
Credit cards, debit cards and contactless
Access
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
At the store
Fitting room, LGBTQ+ friendly, Clothing recycling

Good to know

  • Open Sundays, 11 am–7 pm. Listed hours
  • Expect only part of what you bring to be bought Tip from 3 shoppers
  • Used items, including stained or cheap-brand ones, priced above what shoppers expect Raised by 4 shoppers
  • Cramped, stuffy aisles, and one 2026 reviewer found selling slow Raised by 3 shoppers

When it’s busy

Busiest on Thursdays around 7 pm. Quietest day: Friday. The first hour after opening is usually the calmest.

QuietIts busiest
Resale store where you sell clothes for cash or trade and shop secondhand fashion, including clothing, accessories and jewelry.
Buffalo Exchange, on its listing

22 more within half a mile, 14 not shown

Questions about Buffalo Exchange

How are the prices?

Many call used, stained or lower-quality clothing overpriced. Others find consignment-style pieces reasonable and affordable.

Will they buy my things?

It buys clothing every day without an appointment: 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit, paid the day you sell. Bring a government ID. Some sellers describe low offers or items turned away.

Can I consign here, and on what terms?

Case by case, and only for higher-end items. The split is 50% in cash, paid once the item sells.

Answers come from the facts on this page; some are written with AI, checked against them, and approved by a separate AI review under our publication rules.

Sources: 335 written reviews (2010–2026) and its business listing · its website (buffaloexchange.com) · last updated 7 Oct 2026.

Closed · opens tomorrow 11 am1036 W Burnside St Call Directions