VintageRoam
ThriftBuysConsigns

Buffalo Exchange

Resale chain in Southeast Portland · One of two Buffalo Exchange stores in Portland

Closed · opens tomorrow 11 am1420 SE 37th Ave · map ↓

Buffalo Exchange reviews

3.4 ★★★☆☆ 420 reviews

Used clothing, shoes and bags, with some vintage. People bringing items to sell describe low offers, or only a few pieces taken.

Written with AI from its 285 written reviews and the facts below, checked against them and approved by a separate AI model, Oct 2026. How we write these

285 written reviews · 29% five-star · 42% one or two stars · owner replies to 7% · 35 in the past year · reviewed since 2011

Its 285 star ratings: 83 five-star, 52 four-star, 29 three-star, 36 two-star and 85 one-star, the first in January 2011 and the latest in September 2026.

What its 285 written reviews keep saying
  • 26Friendly staffMany call the staff sweet, kind and helpful; one longtime customer says that has declined.
  • 20Wide varietyLarge, well-organized selection of clothes, shoes, bags and jewelry.
  • 6Fun to browseShoppers say they always find something, including designer labels.
  • 12Prices seen as highOften called overpriced for used clothes, and some say insanely so.
All 13 themes ↓
Buffalo Exchange, 1420 SE 37th Ave
Buffalo Exchange, 1420 SE 37th Ave · photos from its business listing

It buys from the public and takes consignments

Sell your things Yes, it buys from the public. Buys clothing every day, no appointment: 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit, paid the day you sell. From buffaloexchange.com ↗
Consign Yes, it sells things for you on consignment. Case by case, for higher-end items; 50% in cash once the item sells. From buffaloexchange.com ↗

Not stated on its website or listing: donations. Close by, Radical Abundance Thrift Shop takes donations (1.6 mi).

Call (503) 234-1302

All 13 themes in its reviews

What they like

  • Friendly staff26 reviewsMany call the staff sweet, kind and helpful; one longtime customer says that has declined.
  • Wide variety20 reviewsLarge, well-organized selection of clothes, shoes, bags and jewelry.
  • Fun to browse6 reviewsShoppers say they always find something, including designer labels.
  • Well-chosen stock3 reviewsViews on the stock differ: some find shirts and jackets with great designs, others find much of it low-quality fast fashion.

Prices & deals

  • Fair prices7 reviewsOthers say prices are fair, even better than Goodwill for many things.
  • Good clothing prices7 reviewsRecent shoppers call prices fair or reasonable; one longtime customer says it is often overpriced for what they have.

Shopping there

  • Wide size range4 reviews
  • Small store2 reviews

Getting there

  • No public restroom2 reviews

Common gripes

  • Prices seen as high12 reviewsOften called overpriced for used clothes, and some say insanely so.
  • Rude staff8 reviewsSellers and shoppers report rude, condescending staff and managers.
  • High for secondhand6 reviewsSome shoppers call it expensive for a thrift store, one citing $25 for stained Walmart-brand clothes.
  • Priced like new2 reviewsOne October 2025 reviewer says the same prices can be found on sale for new items or on resale apps.

Known for

  • Large, well-organized selection of used clothing 4 shoppers
  • Buying clothes for cash or store credit 3 shoppers
  • Designer-label and vintage finds 3 shoppers
  • Friendly, helpful staff 3 shoppers

A good fit for

Designer label huntersSellers wanting store creditBrowsers who like organized racks

13 themes from its 285 written reviews, written between January 2011 and September 2026, each checked against the reviews before it appears here. Notes under the themes, “Known for”, “A good fit for”, tips and the price note are written with AI from these reviews, checked against them and approved by a separate AI model.

Selling & consigning

Payment
Sellers choose 25% cash or 50% trade; trade cards never expire
Consignment split
Consignment for higher-end items, offered case by case; 50% in cash once the item sells
Pays
On the day you sell: 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit; no wait for items to sell
Selling
Buys every day from open to close, no appointment; bring a government ID
From buffaloexchange.com ↗
Before you bring anything, ask
  1. Do you pay cash or store credit, and how much of the resale price?
  2. What don’t you buy right now?
  3. Do I need an appointment, or can I walk in?
  4. What is the split, and when and how do I get paid?
  5. How long do items stay out, and what happens if they don’t sell?

When shoppers are unhappy

47 one- and two-star written reviews since Oct 2023, each read in full; lowballed or turned away when selling comes up most (29).

  • Lowballed or turned away when selling14 in the last 12 months29
  • Rude or unhelpful staff9 in the last 12 months22
  • Treated unfairly or discriminated againstNone in the last 12 months6
  • Prices too high2 in the last 12 months6
  • Unclear or unfair store policies (bags, fees, minimums)2 in the last 12 months6
  • Long lines or slow checkoutNone in the last 12 months2
One- and two-star reviews by quarter Oct 2023Oct 2026 17 in the last 12 months.

From its own website

What buffaloexchange.com says, read September 2026. Each item links to the page it came from.

Resale chain where you sell your clothes for cash or trade and shop secondhand clothing, accessories and jewelry.

Summed up with AI from its website and approved by a separate AI model.

How it compares in Portland

Big dot: Buffalo Exchange; small dots: 127 other Portland stores.

One- and two-star reviews42% 0100 A bigger share than 122 of 127 Portland stores.
Reviews the owner answers7% 0100 Answers fewer than 80 of 127 Portland stores.
Say it’s too expensive42 per 1,000 0188 More price grumbles than 94 of 127 Portland stores.
4–5 star reviews, past 12 months46% Before48%Past year46% 46% of the past year’s 35 written reviews give 4–5 stars, against 48% before.

Sells clothing, vintage clothing and kids and baby

  • ClothingShoppers mention it · Listed as a used clothing store
  • Vintage clothingShoppers mention it
  • Kids and babyShoppers mention it

Mixed views. 7 reviews call the prices fair, 12 say they’re too high.

Hours and getting to 1420 SE 37th Ave

Monday11 am–8 pm
Tuesday11 am–8 pm
Wednesday11 am–8 pm
Thursday11 am–8 pm
Friday11 am–8 pm
Saturday11 am–8 pm
Sunday11 am–7 pm

1420 SE 37th Ave, Portland, OR 97214

Directions to 1420 SE 37th Ave ↗
Payment
Credit cards, debit cards and contactless
Access
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
At the store
Fitting room, LGBTQ+ friendly, Clothing recycling

Good to know

  • Open Sundays, 11 am–7 pm. Listed hours
  • When selling, store credit pays about double the cash offer Tip from 3 shoppers
  • Picky buying and very low offers, even for good-condition items Raised by 6 shoppers
  • Staff and managers described as rude or condescending Raised by 4 shoppers
Resale chain where you sell your clothes for cash or trade and shop secondhand clothing, accessories and jewelry.
Buffalo Exchange, on its listing

11 more within half a mile, 3 not shown

Questions about Buffalo Exchange

How are the prices?

Used clothing is often called overpriced for a thrift store. Some shoppers do find the clothing prices fair.

Will they buy my things?

It buys clothing every day without an appointment, paying 25% of the selling price in cash or 50% in store credit on the day you sell. Bring a government ID. Low offers and turned-away items are the most common complaint.

Can I consign here, and on what terms?

Consignment is offered case by case, for higher-end items, and pays 50% in cash once the item sells.

How do the staff treat shoppers?

Many find the staff kind and helpful, though rude or unhelpful staff are a frequent complaint.

Answers come from the facts on this page; some are written with AI, checked against them, and approved by a separate AI review under our publication rules.

Sources: 285 written reviews (2011–2026) and its business listing · its website (buffaloexchange.com) · last updated 7 Oct 2026.

Closed · opens tomorrow 11 am1420 SE 37th Ave Call Directions